PdfLuxe logoPdfLuxe

PdfLuxe › Guides › PDF24 vs BentoPDF

PDF24 vs BentoPDF — tools, privacy and processing compared

PDF24 vs BentoPDF is a comparison between two genuinely free PDF toolkits that could hardly be built more differently. PDF24, from Geek Software in Germany, has offered free tools for about 20 years: around 30 online tools that process files on its servers, plus a free Windows desktop app. BentoPDF is a young open-source project that claims more than 100 tools and processes files locally in your browser, with nothing uploaded. This guide compares them only on verified facts about their toolsets and models, checked in November 2026, and ends with an honest third row: PdfLuxe, this site's own toolkit, which shares the browser-local model and states plainly where it differs from both.

Updated 19 November 2026 · Matches PdfLuxe v345.

By the PdfLuxe team · Contact

Open Merge PDF — free

The short answer

Choose PDF24 if you want the established, genuinely free service: around 30 online tools from Geek Software in Germany, about 20 years of history, a free Windows desktop app with a virtual PDF printer, and online tools that process your files on PDF24's servers and delete them after a short time. Choose BentoPDF if you want your files processed locally in your browser and you value open source: it claims 100+ tools — around 90 in its own README, roughly 60 to 70 genuinely distinct once format variants are counted once — and nothing is uploaded. Choose neither if you want the browser-local model with a single stated count and a wider, everyday toolkit: PdfLuxe runs 151 tools free in your browser, and the final section of this guide puts it in the same table so you can judge all three on one screen.

PDF24 vs BentoPDF, side by side

What you are comparingPDF24BentoPDF
Online toolsAround 30 online tools, plus desktop extrasClaims 100+; around 90 listed in its README; roughly 60–70 genuinely distinct tools once format variants are counted once
PriceFree, supported by advertisingFree and open source (AGPL-3.0), with a $79 commercial licence offered
Where files are processedOn PDF24's servers, after upload; files are deleted after a short timeLocally in your browser (WebAssembly); nothing is uploaded
Desktop appPDF24 Creator for Windows — free, works offline, adds a virtual PDF printerNo desktop app
HistoryAbout 20 years of service from Geek Software, GermanyA young project, around a year old (2025)
Open sourceNoYes — AGPL-3.0
LanguagesMultilingualAround 10 interface languages

PDF24 figures are limited to its published toolset and model: around 30 online tools, about 20 years of history, a free Windows desktop app, and server-side processing with files deleted after a short time. BentoPDF figures are from its own README and project pages: a 100+ claim, around 90 tools listed, and an open-source AGPL licence. Where a figure is not published, this table leaves it out rather than guessing.

Round one: the tool counts, honestly

PDF24's count is the modest one and the easy one to verify: around 30 online tools covering the everyday jobs — merge, split, compress, convert, protect, OCR — with the desktop app adding more. Twenty years of being found, linked and trusted is worth more than the count suggests, and this guide will not pretend otherwise.

BentoPDF's count needs one honest paragraph. The headline says 100+; the project's own README lists around 90; and a large share of the list is one engine wearing several labels — PNG to PDF, WebP to PDF, BMP to PDF and their siblings are separate entries for what is, underneath, a single image-to-PDF conversion. Counted by distinct jobs rather than by labels, the toolkit is roughly 60 to 70 tools wide. That is genuinely broad — broader than PDF24's online set — and it does not need the inflated headline to be impressive. When you compare any two toolkits, compare the distinct jobs, not the labels.

Round two: where your files go

This is the round that actually separates the two. PDF24's online tools are server tools: you upload the document, it is processed on PDF24's servers, and it is deleted after a short time. For most documents that is a fair trade, and two decades of operation stand behind it. PDF24 Creator removes the upload entirely, but only for Windows users willing to install desktop software.

BentoPDF was built the other way: the tools run as WebAssembly inside your browser tab, the file never leaves your device, and there is no server copy to delete because none was made. The trade is that your own device does the work, so very large files depend on the machine in front of you. For contracts, ID scans, payslips and medical letters, most people who understand the difference choose the model with no upload — and that preference, more than any tool count, is what this comparison turns on.

Round three: trust, openness and the desktop

PDF24's trust is earned the slow way: a named company, Geek Software in Germany, around 20 years of continuous service, and a desktop app that businesses have standardised on. BentoPDF's trust is earned the open way: the code is public under AGPL-3.0, anyone can inspect or self-host it, and a $79 commercial licence funds it for those who need one. Neither is a substitute for the other — a hospital IT department and a privacy-minded student will weigh them differently, and both weightings are reasonable.

Which one fits which job

The third row: PdfLuxe, honestly

What you are comparingPdfLuxe
PriceFree. All 151 tools; there is no paid plan and no advertising-funded tier to graduate from
Tools151 tools under one stated count, including AI writing and design tools neither rival offers
ProcessingIn your browser, on your device; files are never uploaded. Exception: Edit PDF's optional True Replace (Server) mode, labelled inside the tool
Sign-up and watermarkNo accounts exist; downloads carry no watermark
Honest weaknessesYoung service (launched November 2026), not open source, no desktop app, and browser processing means very large files depend on your device

PdfLuxe shares BentoPDF's processing model and PDF24's nothing-to-pay model, and it is honest about what it lacks next to each: BentoPDF's open code, and PDF24's desktop app and 20 years of trust. What it adds is breadth in one place — 151 tools, 50 interface languages, and AI and design tools neither rival carries. If the model is what you came for, the test below settles the rest faster than any table.

Test the third option on a real file

  1. Take a job you would normally run on PDF24 or BentoPDF — merging reports, splitting a long scan, converting a file — and open the matching tool on PdfLuxe.
  2. Add your file and run the task in your browser. Nothing is uploaded, and there is no desktop app to install and no server of your own to run.
  3. Download the finished file — no watermark, no account — and compare the result with the file the other toolkit produced, on quality, on effort and on how much setup the job needed.

Questions & answers

PDF24 vs BentoPDF: which is better?

They are built on opposite models, so the answer follows your priority. PDF24 offers around 30 online tools backed by about 20 years of service and a free Windows desktop app, but its online tools process files you upload to its servers. BentoPDF processes files locally in your browser with nothing uploaded, and is open source, but it is a young project whose headline tool count needs unpacking. Pick PDF24 for the desktop app and the long track record, BentoPDF for local processing — and read the PdfLuxe row in this guide for a browser-local toolkit with a stated, single tool count.

How many tools does PDF24 have?

Around 30 online tools, per its published toolset, plus extra capability in PDF24 Creator, its free Windows desktop app, which works offline and adds a virtual PDF printer. PDF24 is run by Geek Software in Germany and has offered free PDF tools for about 20 years; its online tools are supported by advertising. A different site with a similar name advertises a much larger count and states itself that it is not affiliated with PDF24, so this guide uses only the real PDF24 figures.

How many tools does BentoPDF really have?

BentoPDF claims 100+ tools. Its own README lists around 90, and once format variants are counted once — PNG to PDF, WebP to PDF and BMP to PDF are one conversion engine wearing several labels — the number of genuinely distinct tools is roughly 60 to 70. That is still a wide toolkit, and this guide states the unpacked figure because a count built from variants tells you less than the list of distinct jobs a toolkit can actually do.

Which one uploads my files, PDF24 or BentoPDF?

PDF24 does. Its online tools process your files on PDF24's servers, where they are deleted after a short time; its desktop app, PDF24 Creator, works locally on Windows instead. BentoPDF processes files locally in your browser using WebAssembly, so nothing is uploaded. PdfLuxe follows the same browser-local model as BentoPDF: files stay on your device, with the single labelled exception of Edit PDF's optional True Replace (Server) mode.

Is BentoPDF really open source?

Yes. BentoPDF is open source under the AGPL-3.0 licence, with a $79 commercial licence also offered. That means its code can be inspected and self-hosted, which matters to technical users and organisations with their own servers. PDF24 is not open source, and neither is PdfLuxe — this guide states that plainly rather than implying otherwise. For most people the practical question is not the licence but where the file goes and what the job costs, which the table in this guide covers.

Does PDF24 have a desktop app?

Yes — PDF24 Creator, a free Windows desktop app that works offline and adds a virtual PDF printer, so any program that can print can produce a PDF through it. It is one of PDF24's genuine strengths, built over about 20 years of service. BentoPDF has no desktop app, and neither does PdfLuxe, which can be installed as a web app on your home screen instead. If a Windows printer driver is what you need, this comparison is honest that PDF24 is the answer.

Which should I choose for private documents?

Choose a toolkit that does not ask for the file in the first place. PDF24's online tools upload your document to its servers and delete it after a short time, which is a policy you have to trust; PDF24 Creator avoids the upload but only on Windows. BentoPDF and PdfLuxe both process in your browser, on your device, so a contract, an ID scan or a medical letter never leaves it. Between those two, the difference is breadth and polish, not the processing model.

Is there an alternative to both PDF24 and BentoPDF?

Yes — PdfLuxe, this site's own toolkit. Like BentoPDF it runs in your browser with files never uploaded, and it states one plain count: 151 tools, all free, with no paid plan, no sign-up and no watermark. Unlike BentoPDF it is not open source, and unlike PDF24 it has no desktop app and no long history — it launched in November 2026. The comparison table in this guide states those weaknesses alongside its strengths.

Related tools

Related guides

This guide is one of 92 step-by-step guides on PdfLuxe — 151 free tools, no sign-up, no watermark. Questions? Email support@pdfluxe.com.